First, lets talk about the individuals Brooks cited. President Obamas approach bears the strong influence of Christian theologian Reinhold Niebuhr, and Brooks knows it. In fact, he wrote two different opinion pieces about the influence of Niebuhr on Obama (here, and here). For what its worth, Douthat wrote one too. On the other people cited, Ive written extensively about the influence of Rev. King on Obama.
More broadly, Obama has repeatedly offered precisely the unifying story Douthat and Brooks assert our country needs, one that includes both the traditional heroes from the older narrative Douthat says appeals to many, as well as figures representing a much broader cast of characters, i.e., those excluded from the older narrative, and who are pretty heroic as well. The 44th president wove all their stories into a single history of a diverse, yet unified people working to realize the ideals laid out at the founding. Obamas story of America is, in fact, just what Brooks called for: a progressively realized grand narrative.
To the chagrin of some, Obamas Americarightly, in my viewrejects both the whitewashed narrative that was predominant in the 1950s and the overwhelmingly negative vision Brooks criticized, one steeped in American tales of genocide, slavery, oppression and segregation. To be sure, no one could be elected president running around talking about America in such a negative. Furthermore, anyone demanding that a progressive candidate must do so in order to earn their vote is only helping elect candidates who espouse the opposite understanding of America. Obamas narrative describes our progress as uneven, yes, but nonetheless moving toward the goal we as a people set for ourselves.
Of dozens of examples in which Obama lays out his conception of American history and national identity, here are a few that span his time on the national stage. From his 2006 book The Audacity of Hope, heres one that offers a unifying narrative paralleling what Brooks says we need:
[The] Constitution...despite being marred by the original sin of slaveryhas at its very core the idea of equal citizenship under the law. . . . Of course racism and nativist sentiments have repeatedly undermined these ideals . . . but in the hands of reformers, from Tubman to Douglass to Chavez to King, these ideals of equality have gradually shaped how we understand ourselves and allowed us to form a multicultural nation the likes of which exists nowhere else on earth.
On the night he won the 2008 Iowa caucuses:
Hope is what led a band of colonists to rise up against an empire. What led the greatest of generations to free a continent and heal a nation. What led young women and young men to sit at lunch counters and brave fire hoses and march through Selma and Montgomery for freedom's cause.
From the first day of his second term:
We, the people, declare today that the most evident of truths - that all of us are created equal - is the star that guides us still; just as it guided our forebears through Seneca Falls, and Selma, and Stonewall; just as it guided all those men and women, sung and unsung, who left footprints along this great Mall, to hear a preacher say that we cannot walk alone; to hear a King proclaim that our individual freedom is inextricably bound to the freedom of every soul on Earth.
In his eulogy for Reverend Clementa Pinckney, one of the nine African Americans murdered by a white supremacist in a Charleston, South Carolina, church:
Removing the Confederate flag from this states capitol...would be one step in an honest accounting of Americas history; a modest but meaningful balm for so many unhealed wounds. It would be an expression of the amazing changes that have transformed this state and this country for the better, because of the work of so many people of goodwill, people of all races striving to form a more perfect union.
And from his farewell address:
For 240 years, our nations call to citizenship has given work and purpose to each new generation. Its what led patriots to choose republic over tyranny, pioneers to trek west, slaves to brave that makeshift railroad to freedom. Its what pulled immigrants and refugees across oceans and the Rio Grande, pushed women to reach for the ballot, powered workers to organize. Its why GIs gave their lives at Omaha Beach and Iwo Jima; Iraq and Afghanistan and why men and women from Selma to Stonewall were prepared to give theirs as well.
Maybe the blindnessof writers like Douthat and Brooks isnt blindness at all, but instead strategy. Maybe they feel like theyll lose their ability to reach anti-Trump Republicans if they acknowledge that Obama has already done what they are calling for someone to do. Part of me can understand that thinking. But another part of me says that the strategic value of a Republican saying: if its a choice between Trumpism and Obamaism, Ill take Obamaism would be far better. Plus, just tell the damn truth if you know what Obama has been doing.
Giving Obama credit for putting forth a balanced, inclusive conception of national identity wouldnt mean endorsing the whole of the Democratic policy platform. Even on the national narrative itself, if Douthat and/or Brooks want to say that Obama hasnt been effective enough in selling the vision he (and they) have described, thats a point we can debate as well. But if they honestly believe that he hasnt been putting that vision out there time and again for years, well, then they just havent been listening.
Ian Reifowitz is the author of Obamas America: A Transformative Vision of Our National Identity (Potomac Books).
Go here to see the original:
The blindness of anti-Trump Republicans - Daily Kos
- WHO launches new initiative to tackle the main cause of vision impairment - December 19th, 2024
- Blindness Advocates on Why There Should Be Audio Description Oscars - Variety - December 19th, 2024
- Diabetic retinopathy is treatable and preventable but only if you catch it in time - USA TODAY - December 19th, 2024
- AI: Could it help prevent blindness in diabetics? - BBC.com - December 19th, 2024
- Health Officials Investigate Rare Form of Blindness Tied to Ozempic - Gizmodo - December 19th, 2024
- Ozempic Could Be Blinding People Trying to Lose Weight - VICE - December 19th, 2024
- What is retinitis pigmentosathe vision disorder in the movie Blink? - National Geographic - December 19th, 2024
- VR shows promise in aiding navigation of people with blindness or low vision - Health Tech World - December 19th, 2024
- Ozempic could be linked to a common cause of sudden blindness, study finds - Quartz - December 19th, 2024
- New virtual realitytested system shows promise in aiding navigation of people with blindness or low vision - Tech Xplore - December 19th, 2024
- Ex-meth user who gouged her own eyeballs out while high says she is happier years after nightmarish episode - New York Post - December 19th, 2024
- Officials investigating link between Ozempic and eye-rotting disease that makes people blind - Daily Mail - December 19th, 2024
- Youngster to 'have eye removed' after minor fall - but NHS waitlist 'over 3 years' - NationalWorld - December 19th, 2024
- Restoring Vision: The Promise of Stem Cells in Healing Blindness - This is Local London - December 19th, 2024
- COAVS and Fred Hollows Foundation strengthen efforts to combat blindness in Pakistan - 24newshd - December 19th, 2024
- Study finds link between Ozempic and increased risk of vision loss - The Express Tribune - December 19th, 2024
- Going blind at 33 is devastating I wont see my childrens faces as they grow up - The Telegraph - December 19th, 2024
- Europol terror report reveals stark blindness about where the danger lies - Gript - December 19th, 2024
- Elton John lost his vision; signs and symptoms of eye infections that can cause blindness - The Times of India - December 6th, 2024
- Elton John's battle with blindness: How 77-year-old star's husband David Furnish guided him around premiere as - Daily Mail - December 6th, 2024
- Experimental study shows connection between COVID infection and age-related blindness - Medical Xpress - December 6th, 2024
- Elton John confirms shocking blindness after severe infection fight: I havent been able to see.. - Hindustan Times - December 6th, 2024
- Yes, an Eye Infection *Can* Lead To Vision Loss Heres How - Katie Couric Media - December 6th, 2024
- Elton John Battling Partial Blindness After Serious Eye Infection - Digital Music News - December 6th, 2024
- CU Anschutz researchers working to cure blindness through total eye transplantation - 9News.com KUSA - December 6th, 2024
- Elton John lost his vision from an eye infection. Here's why that might happenand how to prevent it - Fortune - December 6th, 2024
- Elton John announces blindness due to infection - CBS19.tv KYTX - December 6th, 2024
- David Frost: I suffer from face blindness. As a politician, being unable to identify people is agony - The Telegraph - December 6th, 2024
- Hes still standing how Elton John has survived far worse than blindness - The Telegraph - December 6th, 2024
- Foundation Fighting Blindness Partners with University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus and Other Leading Institutions to Secure Up to $46 Million... - December 6th, 2024
- Walmart helping low vison and blind customers shop with new app - KSLA - December 6th, 2024
- Elton John Says He Is Blind In The Right Eye Due to An Infection; What Is It All About? - Times Now - December 6th, 2024
- Trumps Win: The Blindness of Republicans and Democrats - The Times of Israel - December 6th, 2024
- Heres every song on The Agency soundtrack - NME - December 6th, 2024
- Elton John's worrying health battles in full as he confirms blindness - The Mirror - December 6th, 2024
- Symptoms of serious eye infections after Elton John says he is now blind - LADbible - December 6th, 2024
- Shocking! Elton John Reveals Blindness After Severe Eye Infection: Havent Been Able To... - Republic World - December 6th, 2024
- Face blindness will be examined as part of new project - BBC - December 6th, 2024
- Make your Word documents accessible to people with disabilities - November 27th, 2024
- Make your Word documents accessible to everyone with Accessibility ... - November 27th, 2024
- Use color and contrast for accessibility in Microsoft 365 - Microsoft ... - November 27th, 2024
- Accessibility tools for Word - Microsoft Support - November 27th, 2024
- Rules for the Accessibility Checker - Microsoft Support - November 27th, 2024
- Everything you need to know to write effective alt text - November 27th, 2024
- Create or edit a hyperlink - Microsoft Support - November 27th, 2024
- Video: Check the accessibility of your document - Microsoft Support - November 27th, 2024
- Woman lives with unique condition that means she can still see where things are despite being blind - LADbible - November 27th, 2024
- Arrogance and inherent blindness: Civil probe slams Netanyahu for Oct. 7 failures - The Times of Israel - November 27th, 2024
- Are pistachios the secret to preventing blindness as you age? - The Times of India - November 27th, 2024
- AI is helping people with blindness navigate the world around them - Spectrum News 1 - November 27th, 2024
- Unraveling the Mysteries of Cerebral/Cortical Visual Impairment | Newswise - Newswise - November 27th, 2024
- The silent struggles of color blind students in the UK - News-Medical.Net - November 27th, 2024
- An ideal way to treat Indias corneal blindness problem - The Hindu - November 27th, 2024
- Elle Fanning Has Blush Blindness (and She's Not Afraid to Say It!)This $13 Product Is Key - Who What Wear - November 27th, 2024
- This simple nut is the key to fighting age-related blindness - The Economic Times - November 27th, 2024
- Morning Open Thread: To Lose in Ignorant Blindness What We Might Hold Fast - Daily Kos - November 27th, 2024
- The Murder Capital confirm details of third album Blindness - DIY Magazine - November 27th, 2024
- World report on vision - World Health Organization (WHO) - November 16th, 2024
- Eye care, vision impairment and blindness programme - November 16th, 2024
- $45,000 Raised to benefit SGML Eye Hospital near Ujjain, India for rural and underserved population to prevent blindness - The Indian Panorama - November 16th, 2024
- Foundation Fighting Blindness Funds 35 New Research Grants in FY2024, Renames Key Program to Honor Former Board Chair - PR Newswire - November 16th, 2024
- Fighting blindness with Love Tags - WFLA - November 16th, 2024
- Woman With Rare Disease Waiting For Blindness To 'Cure' Hallucinations - News18 - November 16th, 2024
- Color Blindness Market Is Anticipated To Grow In A Promising - openPR - November 16th, 2024
- Towards a truer vision of broader inclusivity - The New Indian Express - November 16th, 2024
- WHO launches first World report on vision - October 22nd, 2024
- Eye health, vision impairment and blindness - World Health Organization ... - October 22nd, 2024
- Onchocerciasis - World Health Organization (WHO) - October 22nd, 2024
- Eye care, vision impairment and blindness: Refractive errors - October 22nd, 2024
- Blindness Prevention and Control - World Health Organization (WHO) - October 22nd, 2024
- Onchocerciasis (river blindness) - World Health Organization (WHO) - October 22nd, 2024
- Trachoma - World Health Organization (WHO) - October 22nd, 2024
- Blindness is not a curse to be broken - America: The Jesuit Review - October 22nd, 2024
- Alfred University gives away two pairs of EnChroma glasses for color blindness - www.alfred.edu - October 22nd, 2024
- All the Plants We Cannot See - The Revelator - October 22nd, 2024
- ASI Power Summit 2024: How Blindness Helped Michael Hingson Survive the 9/11 Attacks - ASI - October 22nd, 2024
- People with blindness and their allies rally outside Uber and Lyft over ride denials - The Mercury News - October 22nd, 2024
- New Study Links Ozempic to BlindnessBut They Can Actually Protect Your Eyes - First For Women - October 22nd, 2024
- Conservatives Use Trump Assassination Attempt to Target Women in Anti-Diversity War - The American Prospect - October 22nd, 2024
- Google AI to help detect preventable blindness in India and Thailand - Techloy - October 22nd, 2024