In April 2018, California authorities revealed that theyd used a novel investigative technique to arrest a man they called the Golden State Killer, a serial murderer whod escaped capture for decades.
For the first time, police had submitted DNA from a crime scene into a consumer DNA database, where information about distant relatives helped them identify a suspect.
The announcement kindled a revolution in forensics that has since helped solve more than 50 rapes and homicides in 29 states.
But earlier this year, that online database changed its privacy policy to restrict law enforcement searches, and since then, these cold cases have become much harder to crack. The change is allowing some criminals who could be identified and caught to remain undetected and unpunished, authorities say.
There are cases that wont get solved or will take longer to solve, Lori Napolitano, the chief of forensic services at the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, said.
The switch was imposed by GEDmatch, a free website where people share their DNA profiles in hopes of finding relatives. The company had faced criticism for allowing police to search profiles without users permission, and decided that it would rather make sure members understood explicitly how investigators were using the site. So, it altered its terms of service to automatically exclude all members from law enforcement searches and left it to them to opt in.
Overnight, the number of profiles available to law enforcement dropped from more than 1 million to zero. While the pool has grown slowly since then, as more people click a police-shield icon on GEDmatch allowing authorities to see their profile, cases remain more difficult to solve, investigators say.
CeCe Moore, a leading specialist in using DNA evidence and family trees to identify criminal suspects a method known as investigative genetic genealogy depends on GEDmatch for her work. After entering a suspects DNA profile into the site, she reviews the results and assesses the likelihood of law enforcement being able to determine the suspects identity. She then scores each case from 1 to 5, 1 being a sure thing and 5 a long shot.
Im giving a lot more fives than I used to, said Moore, who helped solve several cases using GEDmatch before the site changed its terms of service, including the 1987 killing of a young Canadian couple, the 1988 murder of an 8-year-old Indiana girl and the 1992 rape and strangulation of a Pennsylvania schoolteacher.
This sharp drop in the usefulness of a promising technology has sparked an effort by law enforcement authorities and researchers like Moore to convince the public to take action. These groups hope to persuade more Americans to obtain their DNA profiles from direct-to-consumer genetic testing companies most of which have large databases but dont allow law enforcement searches and share them publicly, including with law enforcement, on databases like GEDmatch. One direct-to-consumer company, FamilyTreeDNA, allows law enforcement to search its database, but charges for it and limits results.
Some people are reluctant, worried that their DNA profiles will be hacked or used against their wishes, whether in the pursuit of a criminal or in the sale of data to health care companies. There are also concerns that DNA sharing will lead to the end of anonymity.
But law enforcement authorities and genetic sleuths who work with them argue that there is greater public good in helping to keep killers and rapists off the streets.
In the interest of public safety, dont you want to make it easy for people to be caught? said Colleen Fitzpatrick, a genetic genealogist who co-founded the DNA Doe Project, which identifies unknown bodies, and runs IdentiFinders, which helps find suspects in old crimes. Police really want to do their job. Theyre not after you. They just want to make you safe.
To illustrate those points, investigators tell the story of Angie Dodge.
Dodge, 18, was raped and murdered in 1996 in her Idaho Falls, Idaho, apartment. A year later, a man confessed to the crime, and although he later recanted and his DNA didnt match that of semen left on Dodges body, he was convicted of participating in the killing and sentenced to life in prison.
Dodges mother grew convinced that the prisoner, Christopher Tapp, was not her daughters killer. She pressed authorities to reopen the case. In 2017, Tapp was freed in a deal with prosecutors in which his conviction of aiding and abetting the murder remained.
Let our news meet your inbox. The news and stories that matters, delivered weekday mornings.
So did the question of who left their DNA at the crime scene.
Almost a year later, California authorities said theyd used genetic genealogy to catch the Golden State Killer.
The announcement generated a surge of interest in the technique, as genetic genealogists teamed up with private companies to sell their services to law enforcement. (Public crime labs are not equipped to do the kind of DNA analysis required, and police generally arent fluent in methods used to build family trees.) Parabon NanoLabs was the first, hiring Moore to run its genetic genealogy services. Idaho Falls police asked the company to try it.
Parabon submitted the Dodge suspects DNA profile into GEDmatch in May 2018, but the DNA was so degraded that, even with more than 1 million profiles to compare against, the connections were sparse. Moore decided that genetic genealogy wouldnt work and declined to take up the case.
But Dodges mother, Carol, begged Moore to keep trying. Moore relented and examined the connections more closely. With help from her team of genetic genealogists, she explored a series of leads that didnt pan out. They kept at it for months, eventually discovering a new branch of the suspects family tree and a potential suspect.
Police followed that man, collecting a cigarette butt he discarded and using it to obtain his DNA. It matched the crime scene profile, and in May 2019 Brian Leigh Dripps confessed, police said. A few weeks later, Tapp was exonerated. Dripps is awaiting trial.
Moore chronicled that search at a recent gathering of genetic researchers, investigators, prosecutors and lab technicians in Palm Springs, California. If she had been working on the Dodge case after GEDmatch limited access to its database, she told attendees of the International Symposium on Human Identification, this case would not have been able to be solved by genetic genealogy.
She said she understood why GEDmatchs owners made the decision, but the result was allowing some violent criminals to remain free for longer than they would have been with the full power of genetic genealogy. She pleaded with her audience to take DNA tests and upload their profiles into GEDmatch.
We dont want this very valuable tool to slip out of our hands, Moore said.
Curtis Rogers didnt ask for this.
Rogers, 81, works in Florida as a court-appointed guardian for the elderly. He founded GEDmatch as a free public service in 2010 after being inspired by his own experience connecting with people who shared his last name. He partnered with a computer programmer who wrote software that made it easy for people to find relatives through certain shared pieces of genetic material. The site became popular among professional and amateur genealogists, and as direct-to-consumer genetic testing services grew, GEDmatch enabled people to compare their DNA profiles in a single place.
Rogers knew little of law enforcements interest in his website until the Golden State Killer announcement. The news upset Rogers and some members. But he eventually accepted the sites role in solving violent crimes where other forensic techniques including searches for matches in criminal DNA databases had failed.
I am not totally comfortable with GEDmatch being used to catch violent criminals but I doubt it would be possible to prevent it, Rogers told NBC News last year. I feel it is important to make sure all our users are educated to the possible uses of GEDmatch so they can make up their own minds.
As law enforcement searches of his site surged, Rogers imposed a few restrictions. He allowed investigators to pursue leads on homicides and rapes, but not less serious crimes like assaults.
Then, late last year, police in Utah asked Rogers to use the site to investigate an attack on an elderly church organist, who was seriously hurt but survived. Rogers agreed, and police used GEDmatch to identify a 17-year-old suspect, who was arrested in April.
But that bending of Rogers own rules on how police could use GEDmatch triggered a backlash that led him to change the sites terms of service. On May 18, all GEDmatch members were removed from law enforcement searches and offered a chance to opt in if they wanted to be included.
Ethicists said the decision ensured that users would be properly informed about how their profiles would be used.
People using genetic genealogy databases for their own purposes never anticipated this kind of access to their genetic information or that information being used to identify people theyre related to, said Amy McGuire, director of the Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy at the Baylor College of Medicine.
There is a genuine tension between wanting to protect consumers and be respectful of their wishes and recognizing that working with law enforcement provides a social benefit, she said.
A Baylor College of Medicine survey last year found 91 percent of respondents favored law enforcement using consumer DNA databases to solve violent crimes, and 46 percent for nonviolent crimes.
But with fewer links from GEDmatch to examine, investigators now have to spend more time seeking connections that could lead them to a killer. That means chasing down more leads, or asking innocent distant relatives to submit their DNA for genetic testing in hopes that their profile will help fill out the family tree. That kind of target testing raises its own set of privacy concerns.
You only need to look at the pace of press releases since the time of the Golden State Killer and see that there was virtually one every week, if not more, and the pace of those cases being solved has reduced itself, said Anne Marie Schubert, the district attorney in Sacramento County, California, where she oversaw the Golden State Killer investigation.
The limited GEDmatch access ultimately means higher costs for law enforcement who turn for help to Parabon, which dominates the private market for such work, or FamilyTreeDNA, one of the earliest direct-to-consumer genetic testing companies.
It also means that more cases might remain unsolved.
If I had a larger team, we would certainly try more cases, Moore said. But because agencies are paying Parabon, we dont want them to waste valuable resources or give false hopes.
Rogers says he has done the right thing for his members, and for the field he loves.
We are here for genealogists, not for law enforcement, he said. On the other hand, law enforcement is here to stay. I feel a big obligation to make sure its used properly. I dont want some half-cocked law enforcement person to do something that creates a story and ruins everything for everyone.
Rogers has sent emails to members urging them to allow law enforcement to search their profiles, linking to a video message from a relative of one of the Golden State Killers victims.
Many of these families have suffered for decades. They need your support, he wrote in an email to members. We hope you will encourage others who have been genealogically DNA tested to also add their information. We believe it is the caring thing to do.
So far, Rogers said, 181,000 members have opted in. Thats far from the critical mass of 1 million that some researchers say is needed to solve cold cases with regularity. It could be many months, and perhaps years, before GEDmatchs law enforcement-accessible database reaches that size.
Im sorry we had to do this. However, I feel very strongly that when we bit the bullet and did what we did, we set the whole future on a much stronger base, Rogers said of genealogy. Two or three years from now, this whole thing will be forgotten.
Here is the original post:
Police were cracking cold cases with a DNA website. Then the fine print changed. - NBC News
- Genetics - National Geographic Society - March 28th, 2025
- Genetics: Introduction, law of inheritance and Sex Determination - BYJU'S - March 28th, 2025
- Genetics, ecology and evolution of phage satellites - Nature.com - March 28th, 2025
- As a geneticist, I will not mourn 23andMe and its jumble of useless health information | Adam Rutherford - The Guardian - March 28th, 2025
- Rare loss-of-function variants in HECTD2 and AKAP11 confer risk of bipolar disorder - Nature.com - March 28th, 2025
- With 23andMe filing for bankruptcy, what happens to consumers genetic data? - The Conversation Indonesia - March 28th, 2025
- A genetic tree as a movie: Moving beyond the still portrait of ancestry - Phys.org - March 28th, 2025
- Genetic mutations linked to Marek's disease in chickens identified - Phys.org - March 28th, 2025
- 23andMe is looking to sell customers genetic data. Heres how to delete it - CNN - March 28th, 2025
- Horses Pulled Off a Genetic Trick Only Viruses Were Thought to Use - SciTechDaily - March 28th, 2025
- CONSUMER ALERT: Warning 23AndMe Customers That Their Private Genetic Data May Be at Risk - Office of the Attorney General for the District of Columbia - March 28th, 2025
- A new study reveals the genetic change that made horses so athletic - KUOW News and Information - March 28th, 2025
- "Mystery ancestors" gave humans 20% of our current DNA, but who were they? - Earth.com - March 28th, 2025
- Correcting the Mutation Behind a Genetic Eye Disease - The Scientist - March 28th, 2025
- Your DNA is safe here: The AncestryDNA Genetic Test Kit is only $39 now - New York Post - March 28th, 2025
- 23andMe Is Bankrupt. Heres What You Need to Know About Your Genetic Data. - The Wall Street Journal - March 28th, 2025
- Commentary: 23andMe files for bankruptcy, putting its hoard of personal health information at risk - Los Angeles Times - March 28th, 2025
- DNA Microscopy Creates 3D Maps of Life From the Inside Out - SciTechDaily - March 28th, 2025
- Eugenics Must Be Included in Genetics Curriculum: Prof - Mirage News - March 28th, 2025
- 11-minute video on human genetics can make people more accepting of others, reveals new study - Hindustan Times - February 24th, 2025
- Advancing Cancer Genetic Testing to Improve Prevention and Patient Treatment - The Scientist - February 24th, 2025
- Environmental factors, lifestyle choices have greater impact on health than genes, study finds - ABC News - February 24th, 2025
- Study finds lifestyle, environment have greater impact on lifespan than genetics - CBS Boston - February 24th, 2025
- Safeguard repressor locks hepatocyte identity and blocks liver cancer - Nature.com - February 24th, 2025
- Mass spectrometry-based mapping of plasma protein QTLs in children and adolescents - Nature.com - February 24th, 2025
- The Avestagenome Project and TIGS Sign Strategic Alliance to Advance Research in Rare Genetic Disorders - The Tribune India - February 24th, 2025
- Researchers make breakthrough discovery after studying genetics of trees: 'There is a need for proactive conservation' - MSN - February 24th, 2025
- iPSCs and iPSC-derived cells as a model of human genetic and epigenetic variation - Nature.com - February 24th, 2025
- Beyond genetics: The biggest factors that influence health and aging - Earth.com - February 24th, 2025
- Genetic diversity and dietary adaptations of the Central Plains Han Chinese population in East Asia - Nature.com - February 24th, 2025
- How a uniquely human genetic tweak changed the voices of mice - NPR - February 24th, 2025
- Genetic evidence identifies a causal relationship between EBV infection and multiple myeloma risk - Nature.com - February 24th, 2025
- Genetic markers of early response to lurasidone in acute schizophrenia - Nature.com - February 24th, 2025
- Bupa to offer first genetic test for disease prediction in UK - The Times - February 24th, 2025
- Advancing Therapeutic Knowledge of Genetic Influence in ALS: Matthew B. Harms, MD - Neurology Live - February 24th, 2025
- Association of dietary carbohydrate ratio, caloric restriction, and genetic factors with breast cancer risk in a cohort study - Nature.com - February 24th, 2025
- Evaluation of polygenic scores for hypertrophic cardiomyopathy in the general population and across clinical settings - Nature.com - February 24th, 2025
- Familiar autism-linked genes emerge from first analysis of Latin American cohort - The Transmitter: Neuroscience News and Perspectives - February 24th, 2025
- Almost 90% of people would agree to genetic testing to tailor medication use, survey finds - Medical Xpress - February 24th, 2025
- Largest Genetic Study of Bipolar Disorder Identifies 298 Regions of the Genome That Increase Risk for the Condition - Mount Sinai - January 27th, 2025
- Study Sheds Light On The Origin Of Earth Lifes Genetic Code - Astrobiology News - January 27th, 2025
- Largest study on the genetics of bipolar disorder to date gives new insights into the underlying biology - Medical Xpress - January 27th, 2025
- Genetic Swiss Army Knife: New Tool For Gene Editing And Therapy - Forbes - January 27th, 2025
- Uhm Ji-won says the power of genetics is undeniable with Hyun Bin and Son Ye-jin's son - - January 27th, 2025
- Integrative proteogenomic analysis identifies COL6A3-derived endotrophin as a mediator of the effect of obesity on coronary artery disease -... - January 27th, 2025
- Genetic analysis reveals the genetic diversity and zoonotic potential of Streptococcus dysgalactiae isolates from sheep - Nature.com - January 27th, 2025
- Eight psychiatric disorders share the same genetic causes, study says - Medical Xpress - January 27th, 2025
- Exploring genetic associations and drug targets for mitochondrial proteins and schizophrenia risk - Nature.com - January 27th, 2025
- Predictive Genetic Testing and Consumer Genomics Market - GlobeNewswire - January 27th, 2025
- Evolution without sex: How mites have survived for millions of years - EurekAlert - January 27th, 2025
- Our Understanding of Rules that Produce Lifes Genetic Code May Require a Revision - DISCOVER Magazine - January 27th, 2025
- Personalized therapy for rare genetic diseases: Patient-derived organoids offer new hope - Medical Xpress - January 27th, 2025
- The One Thing That's More Important for Longevity Than Your Genes - Parade Magazine - January 27th, 2025
- Complete recombination map of the human genome created - Medical Xpress - January 27th, 2025
- Evidence of genetic determination of annual movement strategies in medium-sized raptors - Nature.com - January 27th, 2025
- Genetic study of Alaska red king crabs suggests species is more diverse and resilient to climate change - Global Seafood Alliance - January 27th, 2025
- Smartwatches reveal insights into psychiatric illnesses and genetic links - Medical Xpress - January 27th, 2025
- Unlocking the Blueprint of Human Life With a Revolutionary DNA Map - SciTechDaily - January 27th, 2025
- Largest Genetic Study of Bipolar Disorder Identifies Nearly 300 Risk-Associated Genome Regions - Inside Precision Medicine - January 27th, 2025
- Genetic Discrimination Is Coming for Us All - The Atlantic - November 16th, 2024
- Family connection: Genetics of suicide - WNEM - November 16th, 2024
- Study links heart shape to genetic risk of cardiovascular diseases - News-Medical.Net - November 16th, 2024
- Genetic architecture of cerebrospinal fluid and brain metabolite levels and the genetic colocalization of metabolites with human traits - Nature.com - November 16th, 2024
- Genetic connectivity of wolverines in western North America - Nature.com - November 16th, 2024
- Toward GDPR compliance with the Helmholtz Munich genotype imputation server - Nature.com - November 16th, 2024
- Leveraging genetic variations for more effective cancer therapies - News-Medical.Net - November 16th, 2024
- Bringing precision to the murky debate on fish oil - University of Arizona News - November 16th, 2024
- International experts gathered in Tashkent to tackle rare disease for Uzbekistan - EurekAlert - November 16th, 2024
- Mercys Story: Living life with 22q, a genetic condition - WECT - November 16th, 2024
- Cold case with ties to Houghton County solved through genetic genealogy after 65 years - WLUC - November 16th, 2024
- 23andMe customer? Here's what to know about the privacy of your genetic data. - CBS News - November 16th, 2024
- Single-cell RNA analysis finds possible genetic drivers of bone cancer - Illumina - November 16th, 2024
- Multi-trait association analysis reveals shared genetic loci between Alzheimers disease and cardiovascular traits - Nature.com - November 16th, 2024
- With 23andMe Struck by Layoffs, Can You Delete Genetic Data? Here's What We Know - CNET - November 16th, 2024
- Genetic testing firm 23andMe cuts 40% of its workforce amid financial struggles - The Guardian - November 16th, 2024
- Genetic study solves the mystery of 'selfish' B chromosomes in rye - Phys.org - November 16th, 2024
- Genetic changes linked to testicular cancer offer fresh insights into the disease - Medical Xpress - November 16th, 2024
- Eating less and genetics help you to live longer, but which factor carries the most weight? - Surinenglish.com - November 16th, 2024
- We must use genetic technologies now to avert the coming food crisis - New Scientist - November 16th, 2024
- NHS England to screen 100,000 babies for more than 200 genetic conditions - The Guardian - October 6th, 2024