In 2004, after President George W. Bush cut off all federal funding for embryonic stem-cell research on religious grounds, Californians strongly backed Proposition 71, a $3-billion bond measure to fund this kind of research, even though such funding is usually not the purview of states.
Supporters of the proposition including this editorial board believed it would allow California to stand out as a leader in this field, advance a budding avenue of research that might save lives and alleviate suffering, bolster its biotech sector and fund possible blockbuster treatments that might earn the state royalties as well. Embryonic stem cells are particularly valuable to research because they are undifferentiated, meaning they do not have a particular function, and researchers could conceivably turn them into specialized cells in order to regenerate human cells and tissue.
In the years since, Proposition 71 gave rise to a burst of scientific discovery. Two cancer treatments it helped fund, for blood and bone-marrow cancers, have been approved by the FDA, though neither of those employed embryonic stem cells and could have been funded even under Bush administration rules. It has also supported promising advances in the treatment of diabetes, bubble boy immune deficiency and vision-robbing retinitis pigmentosa, but other efforts have fallen short in clinical trials.
Moreover, the money helped build laboratories and other infrastructure that give California a head start on research and development, making the state the it place for stem-cell research. Researchers in the state moved to the head of the pack for private grants, because projects are less likely to need the time and money to create facilities before work can begin.
Now that Proposition 71 funding has practically run out, the issue is back on the November ballot with Proposition 14, which seeks nearly double the amount worth of bonds $5.5 billion to continue the juggernaut.
This time, voters should reject the measure, with the caveat that the issue could be reconsidered in a couple of years, if its proponents bring it back in better-designed and more modest form and if there are more successes in human trials and financial payback.
We have long had reservations about how the California Institute for Regenerative Medicine, established as a result of Proposition 71, was set up. Though funded publicly, it is not overseen by the governor and Legislature like other state agencies, and its governing board is too large, at 29 members. Those members generally have ties to the advocacy organizations and research institutions that have received most of the money.
The driving force behind the initiative has been Robert N. Klein II, a Bay Area lawyer and real estate investor. There is no doubting Kleins sincerity in his cause. He knows too well the suffering inflicted by intractable diseases; his son Jordan died of complications of Type I diabetes in 2016. His accomplishment in persuading the state to invest billions in a specific avenue of biomedical research has been exceptional.
However, Klein developed these initiatives largely behind closed doors with little to no public input; he has strong ideas about how things should be run on the stem-cell front and has steadfastly resisted more government oversight. Thats fine when hes investing his own money; its a fatal flaw when he is asking voters for nearly $8 billion, the estimated cost of paying off the bonds over time, according to the Legislative Analysts Office.
Kleins role and the bloated structure of CIRMs super-sized governing board have given rise to some serious ethical mishaps, including a board member who improperly intervened to try to get funding for his organization. (He is no longer on the board.) After this and several other examples of impropriety, rules were tightened. Board members must recuse themselves from votes when there is a conflict of interest, but with 29 members who all want certain projects to receive funding, there is too much potential for mutual back-scratching. Instead of repairing this problem, the new proposition would expand CIRMs board to 35 members and retain its troubling independence from oversight by the governor and Legislature, leaving it open to further conflicts of interest.
Proposition 71 hasnt yet yielded a significant financial return on investment for the state or the cures that were ballyhooed at the time. Though no one ever promised quick medical miracles, campaign ads strongly implied they were around the corner if only the funding came through. Proponents oversold the initiatives and voters cant be blamed if they view this new proposal with skepticism.
In the years since Proposition 71 passed, more resources have become available. President Obama reversed Bushs order and restored federal funding, which meant that between CIRM and the National Institutes of Health, along with private grant and investment funding, stem-cell research has been healthy, if not downright flush. That funding has stayed and even grown under President Trump, to more than $2 billion a year, with about $321 million of that in human embryonic stem-cell research. (There have, though, been recent threats to embryonic research from a group of conservative senators.)
The idea was never for California to become the long-term replacement for federal funding. It was to kick-start an industry that would then operate on its own. If that has failed to happen under Proposition 71 as promised, it shouldnt be the responsibility of California taxpayers to fix it. Thats especially true right now, at a time of yawning needs to address the cost of twin health and economic crises and the worsening effects of climate change. Private money for stem cell-work will continue to be available; its not as though research will collapse.
No doubt, the pace of responsible science is incremental and the outcomes uncertain even with the best research efforts. Yet the backers still couch the possibilities in grandiose terms. In a recent interview with the Times editorial board, Klein talked about the money that would be saved by wiping out Alzheimers disease which has so far has frustrated attempts to treat it effectively, despite many billions of dollars in research.
Embryonic stem cell research remains important, and there might be ways in which the state can contribute less grandiose funding while maximizing its investment. For example, scientific research has a well-known valley of death, where many projects cant get funding to make the transition from laboratory to human clinical trials.
Offering some matching help to get projects through that phase might attract businesses and scientists to California, while spending far less than the billions proposed in Proposition 14. Its worth noting that stem-cell work isnt the only kind of research that faces the valley of death problem; its an issue for most basic research that seeks to make the leap to human trials and that might be equally in need of state help.
Now is not the time for a huge new investment in specialized medical research. First, it makes sense to wait until after the election; if Democrats do well, there should be growing support for embryonic stem-cell research at the federal level, which is where such funding should take place. The future of Californias pandemic-battered economy and budget remains to be seen. Waiting also would give voters a chance to find out how well the states stem-cell research projects continue without state dollars, and whether some of the promising advances lead to breakthrough therapies and a return on Californias investment.
There would be an opportunity to rethink and rewrite any future proposals, which should include a far more modest ask of taxpayers as well as fixes to the structure and inflated size of the CIRM board. The institute should also be placed under the same state oversight as other agencies reporting to the governor.
If CIRM needs money for a basic operating budget over the next couple of years, that could be covered by the states general fund. The agency still needs to administer already-funded projects and could use that time to discuss a more affordable path forward. Right now, the state has other, more urgent spending priorities.
Editors note: This newspapers owner, the physician and scientist Dr. Patrick Soon-Shiong, played no role in the editorial boards deliberations on this measure.
See original here:
No on Prop 14: Not the best way to support stem-cell research - Los Angeles Times
- Exosomes Are Being Hyped as a Silver Bullet Therapy. Scientists Say No. - Singularity Hub - December 28th, 2024
- UC Irvine Study Reveals Risks Associated with Direct-to-Consumer Ads for Stem Cell and Exosome COVID-19 Therapies - India Education Diary - November 18th, 2023
- STEM | Description, Development, & Facts | Britannica - January 31st, 2023
- What is STEM Education? | Live Science - January 31st, 2023
- Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math, including Computer Science - ed - January 23rd, 2023
- What Does STEM Stand For? Definition, Degrees and More - January 23rd, 2023
- What Is STEM? - Definition & Resources for Teachers - January 23rd, 2023
- Science, technology, engineering, and mathematics - Wikipedia - January 23rd, 2023
- Stem Definition & Meaning - Merriam-Webster - January 23rd, 2023
- November: labblood-study | News and features - University of Bristol - November 7th, 2022
- Creative Medical Technology Holdings Announces FDA Clearance of Investigational New Drug (IND) Application for AlloStem, a Novel Cell Therapy for the... - November 7th, 2022
- Janssen to Highlight Latest Scientific Advances in Hematologic Diseases at ASH 2022 with Clinical and Real-World Data Across Innovative Pipeline and... - November 7th, 2022
- Type 2 Diabetes Stem Cell Therapy - Top U.S. Stem Cell ... - January 1st, 2022
- Cancer Drug Approvals from 2021 That Patients May Have Missed - Curetoday.com - January 1st, 2022
- Late effects in survivors of high-risk neuroblastoma following stem cell transplant with and without total body irradiation - DocWire News - January 1st, 2022
- The new life of a teenager with a strange tumor on his face after the operation - Market Research Telecast - January 1st, 2022
- Best of what was new in diabetes health for 2021 - Dickson Post - January 1st, 2022
- Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation - StatPearls ... - December 22nd, 2021
- Autologous Stem Cell Transplant for Multiple Myeloma - December 22nd, 2021
- City of Hope presents leading-edge research on blood cancer therapies and its vaccine to reduce stem cell transplant complications at American Society... - December 22nd, 2021
- Adaptation Is Key to Advancing Care for Adult Patients With Leukemia - OncLive - December 22nd, 2021
- FDA Approves First Drug to Prevent Graft Versus Host Disease | FDA - FDA.gov - December 22nd, 2021
- Vera Therapeutics Announces Acquisition of Monoclonal Antibody From Pfizer to Treat BK Virus in Transplant Patients - Yahoo Finance - December 22nd, 2021
- After throwing goodbye party, woman with cancer finds hope close to home in Austin - Austin American-Statesman - December 22nd, 2021
- Dr. K.M. Cherian Heart Foundation & Educational Society Organized Cme Programme & Workshop On Cell Culture And Regenerative Medicine - APN... - December 22nd, 2021
- Namesake of new center a young man in love with the pursuit of knowledge - The Saint Anselm Crier - November 7th, 2021
- Red Cross blood drive focuses on sickle cell disease fight - Palladium-Item - November 7th, 2021
- Shockwave therapy brings new healing opportunities for heart attack patients and hope for people with spinal cord injuries - KULR-TV - November 7th, 2021
- 1st CRISPR Gene Editing Trial Slated to Open in Severe SCD Patients - Sickle Cell Anemia News - April 4th, 2021
- Transplant After CD19 CAR T-Cell Therapy Shows Durable Disease Control in Children, Young Adults With B-ALL - Cancer Network - April 4th, 2021
- Timely Bone Marrow Transplant by Fortis gives new lease of life to a patient with Multiple Myeloma - APN News - April 4th, 2021
- Kirron Kher is suffering with Multiple Myeloma: Know the causes, symptoms and more about this type of blood cancer - Jagran English - April 4th, 2021
- Decitabine Improved Outcomes for Patients With Refractory Prolonged Isolated Thrombocytopenia - Hematology Advisor - April 4th, 2021
- Lake in the Hills police officer and father of 4 kids battling rare cancer forced to retire - Lake and McHenry County Scanner - April 4th, 2021
- Insulin 100: How the road to a diabetes cure is yielding better treatments - News@UofT - April 4th, 2021
- Boxcar Scars Market |Exclusive Report on Latest Trends and Market Growth Opportunities - BioSpace - April 4th, 2021
- Merck Receives Positive EU CHMP Opinion for Updated Label of KEYTRUDA (pembrolizumab) To Include Results of Phase 3 KEYNOTE-361 Trial in Certain Adult... - April 4th, 2021
- BeyondSpring Announces Submission of New Drug Application to US FDA and China NMPA for Plinabulin and G-CSF Combination for the Prevention of... - April 4th, 2021
- Types of leukemia: Prevalence, treatment options, and prognosis - Medical News Today - February 14th, 2021
- Roche receives first FDA clearance for urine sample type for BK virus quantitative test to aid in the improvement of care for transplant patients -... - February 14th, 2021
- Energy drinks may damage the heart, researchers warnshould the FDA get involved? - Cardiovascular Business - February 14th, 2021
- FDA Approves G1 Therapeutics' COSELA (trilaciclib): The First and Only Myeloprotection Therapy to Decrease the Incidence of Chemotherapy-Induced... - February 14th, 2021
- Easter Ross mum of blood cancer tot urges would-be stem cell donors to show the love this Valentine's Day; Alness lass Adeline Davidson's plight... - February 14th, 2021
- Global Induced Pluripotent Market Positive Outlook, Revenue Generation & Leading Manufacturers, Forecast 2026||CELGENE CORPORATION; Astellas... - February 14th, 2021
- Leukemia in children: Symptoms, causes, treatment, outlook, and more - Medical News Today - February 7th, 2021
- After Bone Marrow Donation Saves 9-Year-Old Boy With Cancer, Boston Mom Fights To Raise Awareness - Here And Now - February 7th, 2021
- Understanding bone marrow transplant: The guidelines and the protocols - The New Indian Express - February 4th, 2021
- Why Cynata is hopeful its COVID treatment trial will succeed where others have failed - Business News Australia - February 4th, 2021
- Mobilize family caregivers to speed the rollout of Covid-19 vaccines - STAT - February 4th, 2021
- People With Cancer Should Receive COVID-19 Vaccine, Experts Say - Cancer Health Treatment News - February 4th, 2021
- Evotec and Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf Enter Partnership to Develop iPSC-Based Tissue Therapy f - PharmiWeb.com - February 4th, 2021
- APOE Tied to Increased Susceptibility to SARS-CoV-2 | ALZFORUM - Alzforum - February 4th, 2021
- Transforming Outcomes in Advanced CSCC with Immunotherapy - LWW Journals - February 4th, 2021
- Ashley Cain is living his worst nightmare as his baby daughter battles leukaemia in hospital - The Sun - February 4th, 2021
- Canada's blood supply has a diversity problem and people are dying because of it - CBC.ca - February 1st, 2021
- Autologous Stem Cell and Non Stem Based therapies Market Share, Size 2021 Global Industry Future Trends, Growth, Strategies,, Segmentation, In-depth... - February 1st, 2021
- Merck Receives Positive EU CHMP Opinion for Expanded Approval of KEYTRUDA (pembrolizumab) in Certain Patients With Relapsed or Refractory Classical... - February 1st, 2021
- Merck Presents Results From Head-to-Head Phase 3 KEYNOTE-598 Trial Evaluating KEYTRUDA (pembrolizumab) in Combination With Ipilimumab Versus KEYTRUDA... - February 1st, 2021
- Disabled People Are Waiting, Anxiously, For Lifesaving Covid-19 Vaccinations - Forbes - February 1st, 2021
- Family of Belfast woman Eimear Gooderham (25) share memories and dealing with grief in special UTV programme - Belfast Telegraph - February 1st, 2021
- Single-cell molecular profiling of all three components of the HPA axis reveals adrenal ABCB1 as a regulator of stress adaptation - Science Advances - February 1st, 2021
- The Need for New Biological Targets for Therapeutic Intervention in COPD - Pulmonology Advisor - February 1st, 2021
- What Patients With Cancer, Survivors Need to Know About the Emergency Use Authorization of COVID-19 Vaccine - Curetoday.com - December 19th, 2020
- Every Patient Treated With CRISPR Gene Therapy for Blood Diseases Continues to Thrive, More Than a Year On - Good News Network - December 19th, 2020
- Are Hiccups a Sign of the New Coronavirus? - Healthline - December 19th, 2020
- KEYTRUDA Plus LENVIMA Combination Demonstrated Statistically Significant Improvement in Overall Survival, Progression-Free Survival and Objective... - December 19th, 2020
- Covid-19 can have impact on heart too, say experts - Hindustan Times - December 19th, 2020
- Even if You've Had COVID-19 You Still Need the Vaccine - Healthline - December 19th, 2020
- The Link Between Cancer and Metabolic Dysfunction - Technology Networks - December 19th, 2020
- Diamyd Medical and Critical Path Institute announce data sharing collaboration to develop advanced drug development tools in type 1 diabetes -... - December 19th, 2020
- Gene therapy gives man with sickle cell disease the chance for a better future - Science Codex - December 3rd, 2020
- Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Trial to Evaluate Safety and Therapeutic Efficacy of Angiogenesis Induced by Intraarterial Autologous... - December 3rd, 2020
- Coronavirus Updates: The Latest Treatments and Vaccines - GovTech - December 3rd, 2020
- Graft Versus Host Disease (GVHD) Patient Population, Treatment Algorithm, Medical Practices And Epidemiology Forecast To 2030 - The Market Feed - December 3rd, 2020
- Government of Canada and JDRF Canada announce new research funding to accelerate stem cell-based therapies for type 1 diabetes - India Education Diary - December 3rd, 2020
- Coinfection: more than the sum of its parts - Science Codex - November 19th, 2020
- Angiocrine Bioscience Announces FDA Regenerative Medicine Advanced Therapy (RMAT) Designation Granted to AB-205 (Universal E-CEL Cell Therapy) to... - November 17th, 2020
- FDA Approves Merck's KEYTRUDA in Combination With Chemotherapy for Patients With Locally Recurrent Unresectable or Metastatic Triple?Negative Breast... - November 17th, 2020
- Human mesenchymal stromal cells do not express ACE2 and TMPRSS2 and are not permissive to SARS-CoV-2 infection - DocWire News - November 17th, 2020
- Cleveland Clinic team draws a link between COVID-19 protection and the sleep aid melatonin - FierceBiotech - November 17th, 2020