It was funny once. The perfectly square bit of dirt on the window. The shocked reactions of Craggy Islands Chinese community. The local farmer who doesnt have much time to be a racist, because he just likes to have a cup of tea in the evening. The feckin Greeks
Dermot Morgans finest televisual moment that evocation of Nazi speech-making in front of the greatest window in comedy is perhaps a little less funny now that prime minsters or presidents of Hungary, Turkey, the United Kingdom and the United States are happy and comfortable to spout racist statements, and not merely get away with it but be applauded for it by their supporters.
How have we reached this point? Its the very question asked by geneticist and broadcaster Dr Adam Rutherford. Hes the Rutherford in the BBCs popular radio programme The Curious Cases of Rutherford and Fry, in which he and Dr Hannah Fry try to solve listeners scientific queries.
In the case of the resurgence of publicly acceptable racism, Rutherford decided that a radio show was insufficient and that a book would be needed. How to Argue with a Racist is published this week, and Rutherford will be delivering a lecture on the subject during the Northern Ireland Science Festival.
So, how did we get back here? I find myself asking the same question, Rutherford says. I find myself in lectures thinking how strange it is that Im now talking about this, because these are mostly questions that were parked, in my field genetics years ago. Maybe decades ago. And we keep discovering interesting things about evolution and population differences, and migration, and so on, but the question of how race as a concept relates to biological diversity, that ended a while back.
Having these conversations in the academy is one thing, but as someone who tries to communicate science, to talk about it, as a broadcaster and as a writer, I found I was suddenly having very different conversations. Conversations about race, when we were talking about ancestry In some ways, science has failed to convey to the public what is correct, and so I want to equip people with what current scientific thinking is, so that when the question comes up, they have the tools to respond. To say, Yes, there hasnt been a white man in the Olympic 100m final since 1980, but no thats not because of any lack of African-American ancestry.
Its precisely that sort of casual, inauspicious racism that Rutherford looks to quash with his book. The idea that Olympic athletes with African heritage are somehow better because their genes are imbued with extra strength is rubbish, he says. For a kick-off, using athletes as a test sample is a daft idea because anyone with the sort of genetic gifts that allow them to perform at the highest level is a poor sample of what a broader population is like. Beyond that, theres a simpler rebuttal if those with African heritage are inherently genetically better at running very quickly than others, then where are the Olympic 100m champions from South America, Europe or elsewhere with populations that can trace heritage to Africa?
Besides, tracing your genetic lineage in that manner, looking for secrets and answers to why you are so underprivileged compared with others, is a nonsense, says Rutherford. I do think that part of the change in culture which means I kind of had to write this book is to do with the rise of nationalism and the more open discussion of race. Certainly there are more open discussions of public racism than at any point I can remember in my lifetime. There are other factors, though, such as the rise in genetic ancestry testing kits. Now, theyre not pernicious in themselves, but I argue that they have fostered a misunderstanding of what genetics means, and specifically in the form of a sort of reversion to essentialism. So a notion that were determined by our genes and our ancestry, which as a geneticist I just dont think are scientifically valid nor verifiable to the extent that people adopt them.
So, when you take one of these tests and it comes back saying that youre 10 per cent Swedish, or 15 per cent Irish, these are very broad strokes, that are not scientifically meaningless, but they are of only trivial relevance. But people attribute very great significance to them. For instance, I sometimes talk about the fact that, genetically speaking, there is no such coherent ancestral group as Celts. But try telling that to an audience in Glasgow and see what happens.
Over in Ireland youve got some of the best genetic genealogists in the world, people like Dan Bradley [head of the school of genetics at Trinity College Dublin] who has been tracking the story of the Irish for years, and thats really important work, its important to understand the movement of peoples and the migration of peoples. But theyre always complex. Ancestry is a matted web, not linear family trees.
For example, I have a friend who told me that hes descended from Niall of the Nine Hostages, and they can trace their ancestry back to him. Well, theres two things about that. One, no one is actually really sure if Niall of the Nine Hostages existed, which is problematic for a starter.
The second thing, though, is that if he did exist, he lived in the fourth or fifth century, and thats a date which comes before the isopoint, which is the time at which everyone in Europe is descended from everyone else. So if Niall did exist, and if my friend Bill is directly descended from him, then so too am I. And so are you. And so is a guy in southern Italy, and in Turkey, and literally everyone else in Europe. So if you can attach some kind of tribal identity to that, that idea that youre descended from some fifth-century Irish king, well everyone else is too.
This is a relatively recent revelation. One that has the power to stun those who claim kinship with any royal lineage, or who might have notions of racial purity. The simple, genetic, fact is that your family tree isnt a neat family tree at all. Its more like an overgrown shrub, especially the farther back you go. And because everyone elses is, too, it means that the family shrubs intertwine and merge until, once you go back a surprisingly few generations, were all related to everyone else.
Thus the late actor Christopher Lees claim to be directly descended from Charlemagne is accurate, but also meaningless. Not everyone can prove it using family trees. Christopher Lee could, because he was the descendent of an Italian contessa, so they had the paper trail of her family going back. The whole Danny Dyer story, which showed that he was a direct descendent of Edward III, they were able to paper-trail that too, and very few people can actually do that, but I calculated out a mathematical proof that anyone with long-standing English heritage is also 100 per cent descended from Edward III.
At which point I suggest that we should use our now undisputed and mathematically proven royal lineage to, shall we say, take back control, but Rutherford politely declines my invitation to insurrection. The point is, of course, more profound than working out where you stand in line for a throne. Its the fact that every white supremacist has, if you trace their genetic code back, African ancestry. Every Nazi has Jewish heritage. Every Briton is a mish-mash of European bloodlines.
The problem, of course, is that while all of this science is correct and provable, its also useless in the face of racism. As someone once said: You can argue with a racist; you can argue with a Labrador retriever, too, for all the good it will do you.
Rutherford agrees, but says theres a more important battle, on two fronts, to be fought. Part of the book discusses actual neo-Nazis and white supremacists, because they are obsessed with genetics. And their misunderstanding of genetics makes them think that they can prove some sort of racial purity, which is a nonsense. Arguing with those guys using science is a demonstration of the old Jonathan Swift maxim that you cant reason someone out of a position that they didnt reason themselves into, he says.
Who Im really interested in reaching, though, are those who arent racists, and who dont think like that. But because of relying on stereotypes, or myths, or the cultural sphere that says that race is real, or that some factors are biologically encoded and that those factors segregate by race, I want those discussions to be the ones that are informed by science. Because those people arent fundamentally racist, so when youre armed with facts, and youre armed with a knowledge of history, then I think that is your best route to change. Science is a powerful ally, its the best ally we have, I think. But whats the Bob Dylan line? I know my song well before I start singing.
One of the ideas I explore is that scientists need to get more involved. Its no longer good enough to simply say: Heres the data and let society decide. Racists have no such compunctions, and will use every tool at their disposal to spread their message. So if we. as scientists, sit back and say, Hey, its just the data and I dont know what the political ramifications are, thats for others to discuss, then were volunteering ourselves to defeat, and for our voices to be silenced in favour of populist, emotive arguments, and thats the political landscape in which we now live.
Racism isnt wrong because its drawn from and based on a misunderstanding, or specious scientific ideas. Racism is wrong because its an affront to basic human dignity. What Im saying is, if you want to be a racist, fine, fill your boots, go ahead, but you cant have my scientific tools, my weapons, to justify your position.
How to Argue with a Racist by Adam Rutherford is published by Orion. Northern Ireland Science Festival runs February 13th-23rd. nisciencefestival.com
View post:
How to turn racists genetic arguments against them - The Irish Times
- Age-related genetic changes in the blood associated with poor cancer prognosis - Medical Xpress - April 24th, 2025
- Parts of our DNA may evolve much faster than previously thought - The University of Utah - April 24th, 2025
- It runs in the family: the importance of genetics in pneumothorax - The BMJ - April 24th, 2025
- Inferring past demography and genetic adaptation in Spain using the GCAT cohort - Nature - April 24th, 2025
- Answers to a 160-year-old riddle about the genetics of Mendels pea traits - Nature - April 24th, 2025
- Towards a genetic obesity risk score in a single-center study of children and adolescents with obesity - Nature - April 24th, 2025
- Pan-genomic analysis highlights genes associated with agronomic traits and enhances genomics-assisted breeding in alfalfa - Nature - April 24th, 2025
- Study highlights critical diversity gap in psychiatric genomics research - Medical Xpress - April 24th, 2025
- Daily briefing: Potato pangenome reveals the complex genetics of the humble spud - Nature - April 24th, 2025
- Genetic diversity and adaptability of native sheep breeds from different climatic zones - Nature - April 24th, 2025
- Ginkgo Automation Partners with Aura Genetics to Accelerate Direct-to-Consumer Testing and Innovation - PR Newswire - April 24th, 2025
- Why Sarepta Therapeutics And Other Genetics Stocks Just Got A Sizable Boost - Investor's Business Daily - April 24th, 2025
- Why White Blood Cells were used to study genetic past and future of Indians - India Today - April 24th, 2025
- Association between plausible genetic factors and weight loss from GLP1-RA and bariatric surgery - Nature - April 24th, 2025
- Recent habitat modification of a tropical dry forest hotspot drives population genetic divergence in the Mexican leaf frog: a landscape genetics... - April 24th, 2025
- Barney's Farm Partners with Backpackboyz on Groundbreaking Cannabis Genetics Project - Ganjapreneur - Ganjapreneur - April 24th, 2025
- U.S. Preimplantation Genetic Testing Market Witness the Highest Growth Globally in Coming Years 2025-2034 - openPR.com - April 24th, 2025
- Exploring the implications of case selection methods for psychiatric molecular genetic studies - Nature - April 24th, 2025
- Genetic susceptibility to schizophrenia through neuroinflammatory pathways associated with retinal thinness - Nature - April 24th, 2025
- Who Were the Carthaginians? Ancient DNA Study Reveals a Stunning Answer - Haaretz - April 24th, 2025
- Genetics - National Geographic Society - March 28th, 2025
- Genetics: Introduction, law of inheritance and Sex Determination - BYJU'S - March 28th, 2025
- Genetics, ecology and evolution of phage satellites - Nature.com - March 28th, 2025
- As a geneticist, I will not mourn 23andMe and its jumble of useless health information | Adam Rutherford - The Guardian - March 28th, 2025
- Rare loss-of-function variants in HECTD2 and AKAP11 confer risk of bipolar disorder - Nature.com - March 28th, 2025
- With 23andMe filing for bankruptcy, what happens to consumers genetic data? - The Conversation Indonesia - March 28th, 2025
- A genetic tree as a movie: Moving beyond the still portrait of ancestry - Phys.org - March 28th, 2025
- Genetic mutations linked to Marek's disease in chickens identified - Phys.org - March 28th, 2025
- 23andMe is looking to sell customers genetic data. Heres how to delete it - CNN - March 28th, 2025
- Horses Pulled Off a Genetic Trick Only Viruses Were Thought to Use - SciTechDaily - March 28th, 2025
- CONSUMER ALERT: Warning 23AndMe Customers That Their Private Genetic Data May Be at Risk - Office of the Attorney General for the District of Columbia - March 28th, 2025
- A new study reveals the genetic change that made horses so athletic - KUOW News and Information - March 28th, 2025
- "Mystery ancestors" gave humans 20% of our current DNA, but who were they? - Earth.com - March 28th, 2025
- Correcting the Mutation Behind a Genetic Eye Disease - The Scientist - March 28th, 2025
- Your DNA is safe here: The AncestryDNA Genetic Test Kit is only $39 now - New York Post - March 28th, 2025
- 23andMe Is Bankrupt. Heres What You Need to Know About Your Genetic Data. - The Wall Street Journal - March 28th, 2025
- Commentary: 23andMe files for bankruptcy, putting its hoard of personal health information at risk - Los Angeles Times - March 28th, 2025
- DNA Microscopy Creates 3D Maps of Life From the Inside Out - SciTechDaily - March 28th, 2025
- Eugenics Must Be Included in Genetics Curriculum: Prof - Mirage News - March 28th, 2025
- 11-minute video on human genetics can make people more accepting of others, reveals new study - Hindustan Times - February 24th, 2025
- Advancing Cancer Genetic Testing to Improve Prevention and Patient Treatment - The Scientist - February 24th, 2025
- Environmental factors, lifestyle choices have greater impact on health than genes, study finds - ABC News - February 24th, 2025
- Study finds lifestyle, environment have greater impact on lifespan than genetics - CBS Boston - February 24th, 2025
- Safeguard repressor locks hepatocyte identity and blocks liver cancer - Nature.com - February 24th, 2025
- Mass spectrometry-based mapping of plasma protein QTLs in children and adolescents - Nature.com - February 24th, 2025
- The Avestagenome Project and TIGS Sign Strategic Alliance to Advance Research in Rare Genetic Disorders - The Tribune India - February 24th, 2025
- Researchers make breakthrough discovery after studying genetics of trees: 'There is a need for proactive conservation' - MSN - February 24th, 2025
- iPSCs and iPSC-derived cells as a model of human genetic and epigenetic variation - Nature.com - February 24th, 2025
- Beyond genetics: The biggest factors that influence health and aging - Earth.com - February 24th, 2025
- Genetic diversity and dietary adaptations of the Central Plains Han Chinese population in East Asia - Nature.com - February 24th, 2025
- How a uniquely human genetic tweak changed the voices of mice - NPR - February 24th, 2025
- Genetic evidence identifies a causal relationship between EBV infection and multiple myeloma risk - Nature.com - February 24th, 2025
- Genetic markers of early response to lurasidone in acute schizophrenia - Nature.com - February 24th, 2025
- Bupa to offer first genetic test for disease prediction in UK - The Times - February 24th, 2025
- Advancing Therapeutic Knowledge of Genetic Influence in ALS: Matthew B. Harms, MD - Neurology Live - February 24th, 2025
- Association of dietary carbohydrate ratio, caloric restriction, and genetic factors with breast cancer risk in a cohort study - Nature.com - February 24th, 2025
- Evaluation of polygenic scores for hypertrophic cardiomyopathy in the general population and across clinical settings - Nature.com - February 24th, 2025
- Familiar autism-linked genes emerge from first analysis of Latin American cohort - The Transmitter: Neuroscience News and Perspectives - February 24th, 2025
- Almost 90% of people would agree to genetic testing to tailor medication use, survey finds - Medical Xpress - February 24th, 2025
- Largest Genetic Study of Bipolar Disorder Identifies 298 Regions of the Genome That Increase Risk for the Condition - Mount Sinai - January 27th, 2025
- Study Sheds Light On The Origin Of Earth Lifes Genetic Code - Astrobiology News - January 27th, 2025
- Largest study on the genetics of bipolar disorder to date gives new insights into the underlying biology - Medical Xpress - January 27th, 2025
- Genetic Swiss Army Knife: New Tool For Gene Editing And Therapy - Forbes - January 27th, 2025
- Uhm Ji-won says the power of genetics is undeniable with Hyun Bin and Son Ye-jin's son - - January 27th, 2025
- Integrative proteogenomic analysis identifies COL6A3-derived endotrophin as a mediator of the effect of obesity on coronary artery disease -... - January 27th, 2025
- Genetic analysis reveals the genetic diversity and zoonotic potential of Streptococcus dysgalactiae isolates from sheep - Nature.com - January 27th, 2025
- Eight psychiatric disorders share the same genetic causes, study says - Medical Xpress - January 27th, 2025
- Exploring genetic associations and drug targets for mitochondrial proteins and schizophrenia risk - Nature.com - January 27th, 2025
- Predictive Genetic Testing and Consumer Genomics Market - GlobeNewswire - January 27th, 2025
- Evolution without sex: How mites have survived for millions of years - EurekAlert - January 27th, 2025
- Our Understanding of Rules that Produce Lifes Genetic Code May Require a Revision - DISCOVER Magazine - January 27th, 2025
- Personalized therapy for rare genetic diseases: Patient-derived organoids offer new hope - Medical Xpress - January 27th, 2025
- The One Thing That's More Important for Longevity Than Your Genes - Parade Magazine - January 27th, 2025
- Complete recombination map of the human genome created - Medical Xpress - January 27th, 2025
- Evidence of genetic determination of annual movement strategies in medium-sized raptors - Nature.com - January 27th, 2025
- Genetic study of Alaska red king crabs suggests species is more diverse and resilient to climate change - Global Seafood Alliance - January 27th, 2025
- Smartwatches reveal insights into psychiatric illnesses and genetic links - Medical Xpress - January 27th, 2025
- Unlocking the Blueprint of Human Life With a Revolutionary DNA Map - SciTechDaily - January 27th, 2025
- Largest Genetic Study of Bipolar Disorder Identifies Nearly 300 Risk-Associated Genome Regions - Inside Precision Medicine - January 27th, 2025
- Genetic Discrimination Is Coming for Us All - The Atlantic - November 16th, 2024