I believe in the power of yet. Doctors should, too, especially the one who used my daughters case as grist for a short-sighted article without her permission.
The power of yet is a concept promoted by Stanford psychologist Carol Dweck as part of her research on the differences between growth and fixed mindsets. It tells us that there is always room to learn and to grow through practice, discovery, and research. There is or at least there should be a lot of yet involved in medicine, especially when it comes to diagnosing and treating tick bites.
Back in 2008, my daughter and I were apprentice bird banders. We were both bitten by ticks in the woods around Hopewell, New Jersey, despite taking precautions. I was lucky enough to get the classic bulls eye-rash, suggesting that I had Lyme disease. She pulled two ticks from her abdomen that were not engorged and had been attached for less than eight hours.
advertisement
We both took antibiotics for four weeks. I got better. She has been sick ever since: mostly bedridden for two years, she lost weight, lost hair, and developed postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome an uncomfortable rapid increase in the heart rate when standing up after sitting or reclining. Open sores periodically erupted on her legs and then mysteriously disappeared, which were dismissed as nothing by her primary doctor and two dermatologists.
I stepped away from working as a researcher and news editor to become her caregiver. I put my Ph.D. to work to find the right doctors and treatment protocols, though the well was pretty dry.
Fast forward 10 years to an appointment with Warren R. Heymann, a New Jersey dermatopathologist, to get a better understanding of, or diagnosis for, my daughters condition. After he completed his examination, he suggested that she come back for a second visit when she had a fresh sore so he could biopsy it; otherwise, he had nothing to offer.
Before we left his office, I pointed out the long white lines behind my daughters knees, lines that look like the stretch marks that women often see during and after pregnancy.
I tried to employ the growth mindset, the power of yet approach. See these marks? I asked Heymann, pointing to the white lines technically called striae that had appeared years before as angry red streaks. I told him that such lines are commonly seen in people with bartonellosis, a variety of diseases caused by infection with Bartonella, a group of bacteria transmitted by ticks, fleas, and other vectors.
I could tell almost immediately that he dismissed what I was saying.
I didnt know quite how much he dismissed what I had said until his two-year old essay, Striae Due to Bartonella is a Stretch recently landed in my email inbox. My power of yet approach had no effect.
The story he told sounded like it could be you and your daughter, a friend wrote.It was. In the article, Heymann recounted our conversation about my daughter, which had occurred just two weeks before he published his opinion piece in DW Insights and Inquiries, an online publication of the American Academy of Dermatology. (He didnt ask permission to use this example. I tried to submit a rebuttal to the American Academy of Dermatology, but its journals seem to accept submissions only from members.)
Heymann found an article published in the journal Parasites and Vectors by Ricardo Maggi, co-director of the Intracellular Pathogens Research Laboratory at North Carolina State University School of Veterinary Medicine, and colleagues that addresses these striae. Heymann dismissed their work. Although he acknowledged that no one knows what causes these marks, he conjectured that they occur when excessive stretch overwhelms the dermal integrity of the skin, resulting in a woundtype response with abnormal and/or incomplete repair. Not exactly a power of yet response.
Maggi works with Ed Breitschwerdt, a doctor of veterinary medicine and the man I call the Bartonella guru. He has been studying Bartonella since the death of his father and, more recently, the death of his mother, both likely from Bartonella infections. Breitschwerdt calls Bartonella a stealth pathogen. He and others working to understand tick infections have learned that individuals infected with Bartonella exhibit red striae, now referred to as Bartonella tracks. They dont know why yet.
Heymann overlooked the work of Marna Ericson, an assistant professor of dermatology at the University of Minnesota School of Medicine, who is also trying to determine what causes these tracks in people infected with Bartonella. Her research began when her son developed them. (Ericson happens to be the second author on the Maggi paper that Heymann targeted.)
The dermatopathologist invoked Kochs postulates, four criteria that scientists use to identify agents that cause disease, to dismiss Bartonella as a cause of the stretch marks. Even if confirmed by other studies, an association does not equate with causation this was not a fulfillment of Kochs postulates, he wrote.
Not so fast. Breitschwerdt, who has written about the limitations of Kochs postulates, says it is difficult to apply them when attempting to attribute disease causation to stealth pathogens that can induce chronic, slowly progressive disease manifestations in an animal or human patient. The postulates also dont let researchers readily address environmental, nutritional, genetic and other relevant factors that influence disease causation and do not consider the pathogenic complexities induced by sequential or simultaneous infection with more than one pathogenic microorganism.
Frustrated by Heymanns dismissal, I posted a photo of my daughters sores (with her permission, of course) to an Internet discussion group I belong to called MMI: Microbes and Mental Illness. This 20-year-old closed group, funded and moderated by Robert Bransfield, a New Jersey psychiatrist, has 750 members from 20 countries: psychiatrists and other physicians, nurses, other clinicians, and researchers interested in understanding the association between microbes and mental illnesses.
One of the MMI members, a nurse practitioner who treats a large Amish population in Pennsylvania, suggested that my daughter be tested for Francisella tularensis, a species of bacteria that causes tularemia (also known as rabbit fever), since her sores resembled those she saw in hunters who spend time in the woods. Sure enough, my daughter tested positive for it. And sure enough, tick bites are one way this pathogen can be transmitted.
What I hope readers, especially Warren R. Heymann, take away from this essay is that the power of yet is an inherent concept in the practice of medicine. Doctors must be open to new knowledge, absorb it, and synthesize it.
Physicians dismissed Joseph Lister when he came to America to talk about sterile surgeries, though he was right. They dismissed Ignaz Semmelweis when he suggested that physicians change their clothes and wash their hands before delivering babies and he, too, was right.
The fashion today is to dismiss those trying to understand illnesses for which we dont have answers, like tick-borne infections, as Heymann did. But when he wrote, it must be acknowledged that the concept of these chronic infections is controversial, he was on to something. Chronic infections caused by tick bites are controversial only because we dont completely understand them yet.
Sue Ferrara, Ph.D., a former researcher and editor for ABC News, is an elected school board member in New Jersey, where she learned about the power of yet. She is writing as a private citizen.
Visit link:
Doctors need to embrace the 'power of yet' - STAT
- Merck Veterinary Manual - September 13th, 2024
- Scituate Animal Hospital - September 13th, 2024
- DVM Program - School of Veterinary Medicine - September 13th, 2024
- UW-Madison highlights veterinary medicine on 175th anniversary tour - WXOW.com - September 13th, 2024
- Merck Animal Health Partners and AVC Foundation to award scholarships to future bovine veterinarians - The Fence Post - September 13th, 2024
- Teamwork Makes the Dream Work: The CVM continues push to hire innovative faculty - Clemson News - September 13th, 2024
- Kays Foundation commits more than $500,000 to Arkansas State University College of Veterinary Medicine - Arkansas Online - September 13th, 2024
- A Crisis in the Veterinary World - The Plaid Horse - September 13th, 2024
- Kays Foundation Commits More than $500K to College of Veterinary Medicine - NEA Report - September 13th, 2024
- Project Street Vet and Sheriffs Office Unite to Aid Homeless Pet Owners in Oceanside - Angels in Medicine - September 13th, 2024
- LSU Vet Med pays tribute to pets and their people with giant purple and gold sculpture - The Advocate - September 13th, 2024
- The ideal place to take reptiles pulse - DVM 360 - September 13th, 2024
- 6 veterinarian team at McAfee Animal Hospital bring a loving family atmosphere to the workplace - Valpo.Life - September 13th, 2024
- Just one thing: Allocating practice owner time productively - American Veterinary Medical Association - September 13th, 2024
- Careers in Agriculture: Love of working with animals develops into veterinarian career - Agri-News - September 13th, 2024
- Small Animal Specialist Hospital (SASH) Vets Australia: Heroes of The Pet World - Catster - September 13th, 2024
- Does Your Dog Need Glasses? From Removing Cataracts and Performing Surgeries to Restore Vision, Veterinarians ... - PR Newswire - May 14th, 2024
- Unveiling the Secrets of Veterinary Success: Dive into the Latest Issue of Business by Vet Candy! - Vet Candy - May 5th, 2024
- Nonprofit raising money to save dogs in need of lifesaving medical treatment - Sunbury Daily Item - May 5th, 2024
- What does a veterinarian do? - CareerExplorer - March 29th, 2024
- Veterinary Medicine Overview - CareerExplorer - March 29th, 2024
- 6 in 10 pet owners surveyed in the UK, Austria and Denmark believe their pets should have access to the same healthcare treatment options as humans -... - March 29th, 2024
- 7 horses died in the lead-up to the Kentucky Derby. What is being done to prevent deaths and injuries? - PBS NewsHour - May 9th, 2023
- A Career in Veterinary Medicine - AAVMC - February 24th, 2023
- Building the next generation of veterinary professionals (FCL Feb. 22, 2023) - FirstCoastNews.com WTLV-WJXX - February 24th, 2023
- Veterinary Hospital | School of Veterinary Medicine - September 20th, 2022
- AAFP, EveryCat release guidelines on diagnosis of feline infectious peritonitis - American Veterinary Medical Association - September 20th, 2022
- Don't Fall Behind on Your Continuing Education this Autumn! - DVM 360 - September 20th, 2022
- Using Acupuncture to Pinpoint The Source Of A Horse's Problem - Lancaster Farming - September 20th, 2022
- Stalking Allegations Against Retired Oregon City Veterinarian Lead to $245,000 Lawsuit - Willamette Week - September 20th, 2022
- TheraVet Announces Its Participation in the 2022 ESVOT Congress With 3 Scientific Communications - Yahoo Finance - September 20th, 2022
- Senate committee sets nomination hearing for top food safety official - Food Safety News - September 20th, 2022
- Helping osteoarthritic cats live their best lives - DVM 360 - September 20th, 2022
- Research shows what is driving shelter overpopulation - Vet Candy - September 20th, 2022
- Undergrad publishes theory on immune dysfunction in space | Cornell Chronicle - Cornell Chronicle - September 20th, 2022
- Tuskegee University is named HBCU Institutional Leader by Fulbright Program - Tuskegee University - September 20th, 2022
- New understanding of 'superantigens' could lead to improved staph infection treatments - University of Wisconsin School of Veterinary Medicine - July 25th, 2022
- NC State commits multiple Animal Welfare Act violations, animals suffering and dying - N.C. State University Technician Online - July 25th, 2022
- Pets are also feeling the heat this summer. Here's how you can protect them - CBC.ca - July 25th, 2022
- Oregon's a small world: Politics and vetting veterinarians - Portland Tribune - July 25th, 2022
- Heat emergency with your pet? Don't be surprised if your ER visit requires a drive - News 3 WTKR Norfolk - July 25th, 2022
- Cats Injured in Wildfires at Risk of Deadly Blood Clots - Sierra Sun Times - July 25th, 2022
- Inner Nature: The medicine/poison cabinet | The Unionville Times - The Unionville Times - July 25th, 2022
- 'Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory' Star Peter Ostrum Pursued an Ivy League Education After He Left Acting - Showbiz Cheat Sheet - July 25th, 2022
- New Veterinary Hospital Gets New Name Thanks to Generosity of PVM Alumnus and His Wife - Purdue Veterinary News - February 14th, 2021
- Bovine production-medicine expert joins TTU School of Veterinary Medicine Faculty - KLBK | KAMC | EverythingLubbock.com - February 14th, 2021
- Bovine production-medicine expert joins Texas Tech University School of Veterinary Medicine faculty - KAMR - MyHighPlains.com - February 14th, 2021
- Animal Science and Engineering Researchers Partner to Improve Veterinary Procedure - University of Arkansas Newswire - February 14th, 2021
- Brushing your dog's teeth helps with overall health - Chicago Daily Herald - February 14th, 2021
- ZooMontana's wolf Simpson diagnosed with rare condition, to be sent out of state for surgery - KTVQ Billings News - February 14th, 2021
- Speaking for our canine patients: How to find and communicate signs of chronic pain - DVM 360 - February 14th, 2021
- Roy C. "Curt" Moore - The Gazette - February 14th, 2021
- Diversity Learning Cafs Continue in the New Year - Purdue Veterinary News - February 14th, 2021
- The dean of the UC Davis Medical School discusses the vaccination rollout, patient care - The Aggie - February 14th, 2021
- Veterinary Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients Manufacturing Market Size Worth $10.4 Billion By 2028: Grand View Research, Inc. - PRNewswire - February 14th, 2021
- Purdue Trustees Approve Naming of New Vet Hospital - Hoosier Ag Today - February 9th, 2021
- Veterinary medicine, motherhood, and a pandemic - DVM 360 - February 9th, 2021
- Ohio State veterinary researchers hope to prevent the next pandemic - The Columbus Dispatch - February 9th, 2021
- A world leader of veterinary medicine in Newry and caring for children in the Western Trust: GetGot reveals exciting and rewarding new jobs - The... - February 9th, 2021
- Do pets need to get the COVID-19 vaccine? - WFMYNews2.com - February 9th, 2021
- Texas A&M Researchers Discover Energy Drinks' Harmful Effects On Heart - Texas A&M University Today - February 9th, 2021
- Online presentation to discuss medical care of wild birds - Cheboygan Daily Tribune - February 9th, 2021
- Dog food recall cites trace of deadly toxins - Arkansas Online - February 9th, 2021
- Texas A&M Veterinarians Presented With First-Of-Its Kind Case - Texas A&M University Today - February 7th, 2021
- Veterinary Medicine Market Research Report by Mode of Delivery, by Product, by Animal Type, by End-user - Global Forecast to 2025 - Cumulative Impact... - February 7th, 2021
- What are the odds?: UC Davis veterinary students discover they were adopted from the same Chinese province - KTXL FOX 40 Sacramento - February 7th, 2021
- New forensic programs investigate deaths of unclaimed dogs and cats - American Veterinary Medical Association - February 7th, 2021
- American College of Veterinary Anesthesia and Analgesia - American Veterinary Medical Association - February 7th, 2021
- Veterinary Medicine Market to Witness Huge Growth by 2026 | Bayer Animal Health, Merck Animal Health, Virbac - NeighborWebSJ - February 7th, 2021
- UT's Aligncare Program works with Knoxville organizations to help COVID-19 patient and his assistance dog on New Year's Eve - UT Daily Beacon - February 7th, 2021
- What are the odds?: 3 UC Davis students discover they were adopted from same Chinese province - WGN TV Chicago - February 7th, 2021
- Keeping the Horse's Hindgut Happy The Horse - TheHorse.com - February 7th, 2021
- When will veterinarians get COVID-19 vaccines? - American Veterinary Medical Association - February 7th, 2021
- Appointments, honors and activities - Purdue News Service - February 7th, 2021
- Researchers at Ohio State University are studying COVID-19 in animals and the environment to identify future pandemic threats - WKYC.com - February 7th, 2021
- Hemp Feed Coalition submits the first ingredient application in the United States for hemp to be federally approved as a feed ingredient for poultry -... - February 7th, 2021
- A Corpus Christi native survived a shark attack in the Caribbean. Here's how you can help. - KIIITV.com - February 7th, 2021
- IDEXX and the Tuskegee University College of Veterinary Medicine Announce Landmark Initiative - Conway Daily Sun - January 31st, 2021
- The role of cannabis in veterinary medicine - Vet Candy - January 31st, 2021
- New Year Begins with Special Emphasis on Diversity and Inclusion in PVM - Purdue Veterinary News - January 31st, 2021